For context on the story, please read part 1 for characters.
Sorry for the long delay, got very busy. Warning! This story will deal with betrayal and cheating. If you cannot handle it move on. You have been warned. Enjoy!
***********************
“Hey honey, I’m back,” Jeremy shouted as he opened the door to the apartment with a paper bag. From there, the smell of Chinese food wafted in the air and filled the apartment with a delicious mouth-watering scent.
Setting the food down on the table, he recounted his tale of his adventure to get it to me, possibly dramatizing certain aspects which made me giggle occasionally. As we set the table and pulled the food out of the bag I couldn’t lie, it seemed like he did an amazing job with how delicious the food all looked, and was so proud that he did such a good job. Finally, sitting down to eat we dug in before Jeremy asked “Oh how’d your talk go? Were you able to come to a mutual conclusion?”
A pang of guilt shot through me, as his choice of words and his question made my mind race through the events that unfolded only just before dinner: his sexy body, our “conversation”, the deal, the hand job, and the amount of cum that covered my body which I ate like a dirty slut. Not wanting to be reminded of that, I brushed off the subject with a simple reply “Oh yeah, it was fine. All good now. Shouldn’t be bothering me at night again.”
He smiled saying “Really?! That’s so great to hear! Man, I’m so glad you two could hash things out. He seems like a cool guy that I would like for the both of us to get to know and get closer to.”
Closer. What a funny choice of words. Ughhh god, I just couldn’t get him out of my head. Wanting to avoid the subject right now, I steered the conversation elsewhere as we finished up dinner.
Cleaning up the plates my mind couldn’t help but flashback to him, with literally anything that reminded me of what happened, my thoughts torn between guilt, arousal, but mainly confused. Wanting to alleviate this ache of pain in my head and heart, I thought of the best way I could make it up to Jeremy without giving away what I did. A man’s favorite thing: sex!
This time taking the initiative, since he gets a little confused at times, I put on a sexy smirk and asked him naughtily “Hey Jer, since we both have work tomorrow, why don’t we have sex tonight? A little hurrah to remember you by tomorrow. How’s that sound?”
He was shocked at this brazen behavior sputtering out “Whoa! I mean, of course, that sounds wonderful! But where did this all come from?”
I just gave him a wink replying to him “What? Can’t a girlfriend be a little spontaneous every once in a while?” Wiping my hands with a towel I dropped to my knees in front of him and began to undo his pants. “You know what, fuck the dishes! Fuck your girlfriend instead! Do me right now! Let it all out on me! Make my pussy miss your dick at work all day!” I said in a seductive voice.
“Whaaa…whaaaat! Oh oh… Ummm ok! Yes! Let’s do it!” he shouted excitedly.
Reaching his waist, I pulled his pants and underwear down now releasing his hard dick into the air, but as soon as I saw it my mind flashed to Cato’s monster dick that dwarfed my face. Looking at Jeremy’s seemed tiny in comparison since Cato was over double his… brain! Stop! Focus on Jeremy, not on Cato! Blinking to clear my thoughts I looked up and gave him a sexy look while grabbing his dick in my hand. Before I knew it, my mind instantly and subconsciously compared the two knowing I could easily wrap one hand around Jeremy’s covering almost all his length while Cato I felt like I needed 3 or 4, and even then, my fingers couldn’t touch, not to mention the veins and heat that… OH MY GOD! What is wrong with me!?
Angry at myself for these inappropriate thoughts I tried to take my mind away from them as I took him into my mouth blowing his entire length with ease as he groaned out in pleasure above me trying my hardest to not even think about how much Cato’s dick would stretch my mouth as I struggled to even… “Wow! Thank you! You are so amazing at this honey! Do you like it?” Jeremy asked me, breaking my thoughts from spiraling more about Cato.
Thankful for that I answered him, taking it out of my mouth with an erotic *POP* sound while jerking him off “Oh yes! I love your dick so much! It tastes so good and it so hard to take it all!” Lying through my teeth with that last comment, but I had to make it up to him to ease of consciousness.
Taking him back into my mouth I blew him with one hand fondling his balls before a minute later he shouted out “I’m cumming!” Wanting to make this sexy for him, and possibly wanting to see the difference between their loads for science, I pulled it out of my mouth aiming it at my face as I jerked him off through his orgasm. With a grunt, he shot out 1,2,3 shots of cum onto my face before gasping out as he recovered from the orgasm.
“Oh shit! I’m so sorry! Let me get you a towel!” he said concerned as he looked down Tipobet Güncel Giriş after he had recovered some, seeing his load on my face. Turning around he went to grab a towel off the rack so I could wipe myself off. Looking down at myself, I could barely see a couple of spurts of cum on my face and could easily tell, just from the feel, how little he covered me unlike when Cato drenched me in his cum both on my face and… Fuck, I did it again!
Turning back around, he handed me the towel letting me wipe it off my face secretly thankful I didn’t have to eat it especially after how addicting the taste… ughhh. Feeling I had gotten it all I threw the towel to the side and looked up at him whispering seductively “Ready to fuck me now!”
His eyes widened at my comment telling me “I mean slow down. You gotta give me a second to get hard again but sure that sounds great! Where would you like to do it?”
“Right here! Bend me over the counter and fuck me like a slut! Fuck me until I scream in an orgasm! Make me your bitch!” I whispered hotly in his ear as I walked past him bending myself over the counter lowering my shorts to the ground and giving him a perfect view of my juicy ass that a lot of men would die happily just seeing once.
Letting him recover and watching his dick hungrily, I tried to speed up the process by playing with my ass, spanking it, grabbing it, and groping it for him, moaning out as I did so to drive him crazy. A couple of minutes later his dick had recovered and was back to being completely erect as we looked at each other lustfully.
He lined up his dick up with my pussy and trying to talk dirty added “Ok then, here we go! Take it all!” Shoving himself into me and thrusting himself fast and hard while I moaned out to make him seem like I was enjoying it but wishing I had something bigger, longer, and thicker like… NOOO! That’s not what we are doing! Jeremy! Focus on Jeremy while he fucks you!
A minute in, he already began panting from the physical exhaustion as I looked back whishing, he was even half as built as Cato since then he could… Fuck! I need to stop doing that!
He kept fucking me for the next couple of minutes, having to stop once or twice to catch his breath, before shouting out “I’m gonna cum!” Then turning around, I took him back into my mouth letting him blow his load straight down my throat as I held back my gag reflex at the gross taste.
Falling back to lean against the fridge he panted and gasped out as he recovered from probably one of our most intense sex sessions. “Wow, that was amazing honey! Thank you for that!”
Smiling kindly at him I told him, “Of course, anything for my boyfriend. Tell you what, because that felt so good, ill clean up here. Go ahead and get some sleep, I’ll see you later.”
He nodded and pulled up his pants as he walked toward the bedroom. When he was out of sight and earshot I leaned against the cabinets, pulled my legs close to me, and slammed my palms into my head chastising myself, “You stupid fucking slut! Couldn’t even go one minute without comparing the two! What the fuck is wrong with me!”
I stayed like that just trying to sort my thoughts and get Cato out of my head but no matter how hard I tried my mind just couldn’t let him go. Groaning in frustration from my feeling of guilt and sexual frustration since I didn’t even cum, I got up and cleaned up the kitchen, and headed to bed hoping that when I woke up the next day this whole affair would be out of my head. As I fell asleep, I was happy for at least the peace and quiet since it seemed like he was upholding his end of the bargain letting out a laugh since he was the last thing on my mind before drifting off to sleep.
******************
“Mhmmmm fuck! Please put it in! Stop teasing me! I can’t take it!” I mewled out.
“Please what?” Cato whispered in my ear
“Please put your huge massive cock inside me! Please fuck me like the slut I am! Please make me cum around your dick! Please fuck me!!” begging him at this point, squirming in need as my body was set on fire in anticipation.
Giving me that smirk “That’s what I like to hear, Madi.”
Lining up his dick he held me down assertively then with a grunt slammed himself into me jolting me awake.
“Huh?” I rubbed my eyes so confused at what happened. Coming to my senses I heard my alarm ringing and realized it was all just a dream. I huffed in frustration so mad that my dream was cut off short until I noticed that it was Cato in my dream, not Jeremy. “Ughhh god I’m so bad! I literally cannot get him out of my head.” I groaned guiltily.
“It’s ok. As long as Jeremy doesn’t know or find out then it’s ok, right?” I said under my breath while looking at the sleeping form of Jeremy lying next to me. Glancing at my phone I saw it was 7:00 am “Alright let’s get this day started.” Hopping out of bed, I started my morning routine and put on some workout attire, a pair of older red leggings that still Tipobet Giriş did an excellent job at highlighting my sexy legs and peachy booty, and a black tank top that came down to just above the middle of my ass. I dressed a bit down since I didn’t know who was at the gym during this morning time and didn’t want some old man staring at me lustfully or some old woman staring daggers of jealousy at me. Throwing some extra things in a duffel bag, I headed down the stairs towards the gym.
Upon reaching the gym floor, I saw a wall of frosted glass covering any windows looking into the gym giving privacy to those inside. Looking at my phone I checked the time seeing it now to be 7:15 am. “Perfect. Workout for an hour, then shower, get ready for work, and I should get there no later than 9.” Opening the door, I headed inside looking around amazed at how nice and modern the gym was as almost every machine you could think of to work out your body was here. Setting my stuff down in the cubby in one of the walls I didn’t see anybody else’s stuff and taking another look around couldn’t see or hear another soul. “Wow! Gym all to myself! Hopefully, this is an everyday thing cause that’ll be so nice!”
Grabbing my water bottle and a towel out of my bag, I headed to the treadmills to get a quick stretch and warm-up before hitting the weights. As I turned on the treadmill, I heard the door open and sighed out “Well guess that dream was short-lived.” Continuing my warmup, I looked down at my phone to select my music, and when I looked up screamed “Ahhh what the…!”
“Well, hello there Madi. Long time no see. Did you miss me?” Cato said smugly while standing on the front end of my treadmill.
“Why are you here?” I asked nervously. No! Oh god! Out of everyone it had to be you! Why can’t I just have 2 seconds without you? I don’t even know what to think. Excited? Guilty? Annoyed?
He just let out a chuckle responding “To work out, same as you. I always come at this time every day before I head to work, though it’s always empty at this time so your presence here is… much appreciated.” Giving me a smirk that made me blush. Taking a step to the left he gave a little grunt and he vaulted himself over the front end of the treadmill and leaned against the side railing looking at me.
As he did this, I saw his muscles flex and my mind refreshed of what a tantalizing body he had. His tank top showcased his built arms and powerful chest while his shorts hugged his ass and bulged around his dick. My heart beat faster just looking at him and I had to divert my eyes just to try and maintain a conversation with him before I became horny. Taking a long look at me he said confidently “Might I say your lower half is just as distracting as the top half Madi.”
I blushed at his comment overjoyed that he found me to be so attractive… no! I don’t like this guy remember! “Look Cato, I am thankful that you upheld your part of the deal last night but that was in the past. Nothing like that is happening ever again” I replied as I pressed stop on the treadmill since I finished my warmup.
He smirked and held up his hands pretending he was in front of a cop “Understandable but I was just wanting to get to know you more since we’re gonna be partners…” My heart skipped a beat as my eyes widened both in surprise at his brazen words and the fact that I was excited about it? “Oh, excuse me, gym partners.” He clarified giving me a knowing smirk.
Rolling my eyes with a smile on my face I stepped off the treadmill responding “You just don’t know when to quit.”
He gave me a wink as he stepped off as well standing in front of me as he said “Seems to be a common trait I have with women as beautiful as you.” His comment making me blush again.
Oh, fuck it. His words and body turned me on as no other had in the past and just seeing him drove my mind crazy as it brought out a battle between Cato and Jeremy every time. From being sexually frustrated last night and since I guess I would be seeing him every day at the gym before work, I gave in slightly. Giving him a smirk playfully responding “Gym partners huh?” then turning around and walking away to begin my work out and adding in a little more sway into my hips than normal I added “Maybe… I can allow that. But nothing more.” While cheering internally as he chuckled behind me.
Time flew by as I powered through my Monday workout building up a good sweat from sets of squats, lunges, burpees, deadlifts, and hip thrusts. Surprisingly Cato left me alone most of the time only giving the occasional comment or pickup line if we ever passed by each other.
Stealing glances at him in the mirror as he worked out, I couldn’t help but feel attracted to how delicious his body looked in his attire. I was pleasantly surprised though to see a different side of him instead of the playful flirting side but more of a serious focus whose face of concentration, as he pounded through sets of weights that would crush Jeremy or Tipobet most average guys, made my heart flutter.
We finished up around the same time and headed to our stuff on the wall, packing up our things. He opened the door for me and bowed his head, with a smirk, as though he were a butler and I some high nobility making me blush, smile, and roll my eyes as I playfully let out “You’re too much sometimes.”
We headed to the elevators making small conversation until I hit my floor and stepped out. As the doors were closing, I heard an “Until tomorrow partner.” When I heard the doors close, I couldn’t wipe the smirk off my face at his last line. Getting ready for work I gave Jeremy a kiss telling him I’d be home around 7 and left.
While working, these thoughts kept nagging at me throughout the day. “For what reason would Cato’s presence alone give me more motivation to work and try harder at the gym? Was it some secret drive to try and impress him? But why would I want him to notice me, I have Jeremy? Sure, he’s not perfect but I’m happy with him. Yeah, Cato may be financially more stable, have a better body, and well bigger… a much bigger dick. But no way that he could give me the emotional support and love that Jeremy does, right?”
Arriving at the apartment that night I walked in the Jeremy “cooking” dinner for us both. Kissing him, he told me “Dinner will be ready soon, I think you’ll like it this time.”
I headed to the room to change into more comfortable clothes and walked back out sitting at the table asking, “Where’d you get all this food?”
“Well, we didn’t have any food here so after work I headed to the store and grabbed us some things.” He responded as he flipped the chicken in the pan. “Don’t worry honey I bought it myself” he bragged proudly to show that he too could provide for me.
“Any luck with clients?” I asked hopeful that maybe he got a lucky break today.
“Ehhhh… sadly no. But it’s my second week there so slow and steady right?” he said jokingly that made me give him a pity smile to try and not hurt his feelings.
Plating up the food I took a bite trying out a recipe he’s been “perfecting” for years now. While Jeremy is no chef, he can cook ok. The food wasn’t the best thing I ate but it was alright after a long day of work and he made it with love, so it made it taste that much better. Digging into the food we talked about our day as I made sure to not mention Cato, my new “gym partner”, to him since I wasn’t sure how he would respond. After the nice meal, we cleaned up and watched a show together before heading to bed.
**********************
“Fuck me harder! Faster! Fuck don’t stop! Right there! Ohhhh shittttt yessss!!” I moaned out.
“Tell me what you’re feeling. Let me know how much you like it.” Cato growled into my ear thrusting into me.
“Fuck! I love… ahhhhh… the way your fat… MHMMM… juicy… FUCK… cock fills my pussy… ohhhhh yes! I love how you reach… OH FUCK RIGHT THERE… so DEEP! Please… mhmm… never… ughhh… stop… OHHHH… fucking me!!” I moaned out deliriously.
*BEEP* *BEEP* *BEEP* *BEEP*
Opening my eyes, I looked, seeing my stupid alarm woke me up again from another dream as I felt the heat and wetness from between my legs. Huffing out in annoyance I closed my eyes hoping to continue where I left off but was just left alone with my thoughts of seeing Cato again today. “I need a fucking from Jeremy pretty soon if I kept having these lewd dreams.”
Getting out of bed I got dressed for the gym in a different pair of leggings and a tighter long sleeve top that left some of my toned stomach bare and headed downstairs to the gym. This time when I turned the corner of the hallway, I saw a brief glimpse of him as he entered the gym already making my heart begin to beat faster.
Entering myself I looked around and sure enough, he wasn’t lying when he said no one uses the gym at this time as it was empty except for the two of us. Walking to the cubbies and setting my stuff inside he leaned against the wall before smugly saying “Welcome back partner. It’s a pleasure to see you again.”
Rolling my eyes while smiling I responded “Gym partner. Don’t think you’re the main reason I come here. A girl has to stay in shape.”
He chuckled out “Well I like the shape you’re in. I like your shape very much.” Making me blush as he gave me that deadly smirk of his. “But I’m glad to hear that I’m at least a reason that you come here.”
Realizing what I said before and his response made me blush hard as I turned away not wanting him to see the smile that I was struggling to contain. Not knowing what to say I blurted out “Oh, shut up that’s… that’s not what I meant.”
He just laughed out loud at my reaction. When he recovered from his laughing spurt he smiled and jokingly said “Your cute when you’re embarrassed as well.”
I turned away and headed to the treadmill mumbling “jerk” under my breath as I began my warmup. The rest of my workout today was similar to that of yesterday where we each focused on working out and made very small conversation with each other if we ever passed by each other between sets. I would steal glances at him every chance I got as my horniness was a bit high today considering the dreams I have been waking up to.